Blog

The Goldmine You Already Have: How to Master Follow-Up

Written by Karen Jones | Jul 1, 2025 11:34:28 PM

Land More Business Without Chasing New Leads

Do you feel like you're constantly on the hunt for new leads to grow your real estate business? The surprising truth is, you might not need more leads. Instead, the key to unlocking greater success often lies in nurturing the connections you've already made. If you're not closing enough deals, it's usually less about a lack of potential clients and more about a lack of consistent, effective follow-up. In short, leads aren't your problem—follow-up is.

Think about it: how many leads do you currently have scattered across sticky notes, email inboxes, spreadsheets, or even just in your phone contacts? Dozens? Hundreds? Thousands? Now, honestly ask yourself: when was the last time you genuinely connected with them? And by "connected," I mean a real conversation—a phone call or an in-person meeting. Mass emails, automated texts, or generic mailings don't count. If you're like most agents, your answer is probably, "Not nearly enough."

 

The Power of Persistent Follow-Up

Industry experts suggest it takes an average of 8 to 12 meaningful "touches" to convert a lead into a client. Yet, many real estate professionals abandon a lead after just two or three contacts if they don't get an immediate "yes." Rather than continuing to nurture those promising connections, they shift their valuable time, energy, and marketing budget towards acquiring brand-new leads. Imagine the business you're leaving on the table!

 

Your Simple Follow-Up Formula

Ready to turn those existing leads into closed transactions? Here's an easy, actionable formula to get started:

  • Organize Your Database: Gather all your leads—from physical notes to digital files—into one centralized system. Whether it's a CRM, a simple spreadsheet, or even a dedicated notebook, get them all in one place. Once organized, categorize them by their readiness to transact: hot (ready now), warm (interested, but not immediate), or cold (potential future clients).  And if you need a PLUG 'N' PLUG CRM, I have one to recommend.  It's easy to use, sends excellent content and allows you to track your personal connections to ensure they get done.  Your marketing budget needs to include a robust CRM to help you with the consistent touch- points.

  • Next: Plan Your Outreach: Consistency is crucial. Establish a clear follow-up schedule for each lead type:

    • Hot leads: Daily or every other day

    • Warm leads: Weekly

    • Cold leads: Monthly or Quarterly.  Even an annual contact on special events, like birthdays is a great way to keep the connection going.

  • Cultivate Relationships, Not Just a Pipeline:  Real estate is a relationship business.  Shift your mindset. Your goal isn't just to "work" a list; it's to build genuine relationships. Focus on understanding their needs and becoming a trusted resource.  Your connection needs a good landscaper, who should they be calling, that's right YOU...You need to be their source for everything real estate.

  • Add Value with Every Contact: Make each interaction about them, not about you. Provide relevant market updates, answer frequently asked questions, offer advice tailored to their situation, or share valuable local insights. This approach prevents you from sounding like a pushy salesperson and positions you as an invaluable expert.  And that CRM that we spoke about earlier...make notes so you can pick up on the conversation. Use your tools efficiently, a good CRM will increase your value to your connections by making real connections and not commercial connections.

  • Track Your Efforts: Don't fly blind! Keep a detailed log of every phone call and in-person meeting. This meticulous tracking ensures your efforts are intentional and helps you see your progress.  It also allows you to pick up the conversation of where it was left off earlier.  This shows your connections that you are there for them...they are not just a sale to you.

  • Persist, Persist, Persist: Remember the 8 to 12 touches. Don't get discouraged and give up after only a couple of contacts. Your persistence is what will ultimately convert those leads.  Consider sending handwritten note cards, video text messages or use tools for a personal message that can go out to the entire database while sounding personal and meant just for them.

The fact is, the leads you already possess are a goldmine waiting to be tapped—you just need to master the art of strategic follow-up. This might feel overwhelming at first, but don't let it paralyze you. You don't need to contact everyone immediately. Just start with your "hot" leads and build momentum from there.

Need personalized guidance to set up your follow-up system? Our one-on-one coaching helps you educate, elevate, and execute proven marketing strategies for successful outcomes.

Your success in real estate isn't just about leads; it's about building a sustainable, profitable business. That's why I'm here not just as your Marketing Coach, but also as your resource for all things home financing. For personalized home loan guidance, reach out to Karen Jones, NMLS #307015, at Altitude Home Loans (HomeLoansbyKarenJones.com) I'm also the Founder of Strategy4SuccessNow, and I'm passionate about helping agents like you achieve their goals while helping make homeownership dreams come true.