Blog

The Confidence Myth: Why You Don’t Need the Answers to Lead

Written by Karen Jones | Jan 26, 2026 7:15:00 PM

 

We often treat "confidence" as a synonym for "certainty."

We imagine that the most successful professionals—the CEOs, the innovators, the elite managers—possess a secret vault of knowledge. We assume they move through their day with a mental map for every scenario, never doubting their next move.

But in my years of coaching high-achievers, I’ve found that the opposite is true.

The most confident people aren’t those who have all the answers. They are the ones who are the most comfortable being without them.

The Trap of "Knowing"

In a world that is moving faster than ever, "knowing everything" is an impossible standard. When we tie our confidence to our expertise, we become fragile. If a challenge arises that sits outside our experience, our confidence shatters. We start to feel like imposters.

But real confidence isn't a state of perfect preparation. It’s a fundamental relationship with the unknown.

The Three Pillars of Resourceful Confidence

True confidence stems from a shift in mindset—moving away from competence and toward resourcefulness. It’s built on three specific behaviors:

  1. The Courage to say "I don't know yet": This isn't a sign of weakness; it’s a sign of high integrity. It signals to your team that you value truth over ego.

  2. The Ability to Befriend Ambiguity: Instead of seeing uncertainty as a threat to be managed, confident leaders see it as a puzzle to be solved. They don't view complexity as a roadblock; they view it as the work itself.

  3. Trust in the Process, Not Perfection: They believe in their ability to learn, adjust, and pivot. They know that even if the first attempt fails, their process for solving problems remains intact.

Leading by Example

This shift is especially transformative for teams. When a leader dares to say, "I need more information," or "Let’s figure this out together," they aren't just solving a problem—they are building a culture.

They are sending a signal that says: Exploration is allowed here. Pretending to be perfect is not required. This is how psychological safety is built. This is how innovation begins.

Your Next Step

At different stages of your career, you will inevitably hit a wall where your past experience can no longer guide you. In those moments, remember:

Confidence ≠ Always being right. Confidence = Remaining calm in the face of change.

You don’t need to see the entire path to start walking. You just need to trust that you are the kind of person who can figure it out, one step at a time.

Reflection Question

Where are you holding yourself back because you feel you don't "know enough" yet? What would change if you trusted your ability to figure it out as you go?

Ready to shift your mindset from "Expert" to "Architect"?   Reach out for private coaching.